Hospital rankings
Hospitals in South Dakota with the highest value-based purchasing score
11 South Dakota hospitals ranked by value-based purchasing score in the 2026 Medicare (CMS) data. Leading: Brookings Health System, Sanford Medical Center Aberdeen, Avera Heart Hospital Of South Dakota. Filter by type, ownership and size, choose the measures you care about, and sort by any column.
| # | Hospital | Value-based purchasing scorehigher is better | Net Medicare quality adjustmenthigher is better | Readmissions penaltyhigher is better | Hospital-acquired condition scorelower is better | Value-based purchasing adjustmenthigher is better | Compare |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| National average | 31 | −0.48% | −0.34% | 0.00 | +0.13% | ||
| 1 | Brookings Health System | 51, 94th percentile | +0.44%, 84th percentile | −0.07%, 66th percentile | +1.07, 5th percentile | +1.51%, 94th percentile | Compare Brookings Health System |
| 2 | Sanford Medical Center Aberdeen | 41, 81st percentile | +0.79%, 90th percentile | −0.01%, 77th percentile | −0.86, 93rd percentile | +0.80%, 81st percentile | Compare Sanford Medical Center Aberdeen |
| 3 | Avera Heart Hospital Of South Dakota | 39, 78th percentile | +0.69%, 89th percentile | 0.00%, 89th percentile | −0.73, 88th percentile | +0.69%, 78th percentile | Compare Avera Heart Hospital Of South Dakota |
| 4 | Avera St Mary's Hospital | 35, 70th percentile | −0.61%, 43rd percentile | −0.03%, 73rd percentile | +1.67, 2nd percentile | +0.42%, 69th percentile | Compare Avera St Mary's Hospital |
| 5 | Monument Health Spearfish Hospital | 34, 68th percentile | +0.32%, 82nd percentile | −0.05%, 69th percentile | −0.78, 91st percentile | +0.37%, 67th percentile | Compare Monument Health Spearfish Hospital |
| 6 | Avera St Lukes | 32, 60th percentile | −0.17%, 59th percentile | −0.38%, 33rd percentile | −0.38, 73rd percentile | +0.21%, 60th percentile | Compare Avera St Lukes |
| 7 | Avera Sacred Heart Hospital | 30, 50th percentile | −0.16%, 60th percentile | −0.20%, 49th percentile | −0.13, 56th percentile | +0.04%, 50th percentile | Compare Avera Sacred Heart Hospital |
| 8 | Sanford USDMedical Center | 27, 43rd percentile | −0.15%, 60th percentile | −0.04%, 71st percentile | −0.25, 64th percentile | −0.11%, 42nd percentile | Compare Sanford USDMedical Center |
| 9 | Monument Health Rapid City Hospital | 27, 40th percentile | −0.51%, 46th percentile | −0.35%, 35th percentile | +0.05, 44th percentile | −0.16%, 40th percentile | Compare Monument Health Rapid City Hospital |
| 10 | Avera McKennan Hospital & University Health Center | 22, 25th percentile | −0.61%, 43rd percentile | −0.14%, 55th percentile | +0.36, 26th percentile | −0.47%, 25th percentile | Compare Avera McKennan Hospital & University Health Center |
| 11 | Prairie Lakes Healthcare System, Inc | 21, 20th percentile | −1.58%, 14th percentile | −0.03%, 73rd percentile | +1.27, 3rd percentile | −0.55%, 20th percentile | Compare Prairie Lakes Healthcare System, Inc |
About these rankings
Rankings use the 2026 release of CMS Care Compare data. Hospitals share a rank (“T”) when their values are equal, and only hospitals with a reported value for the sorted measure are ranked. Shading compares each value with every hospital in the country, so it doesn’t change with your filters. Small differences are often not statistically meaningful; use the methodology and glossary for context.
- Value-based purchasing score
- Hospital Value-Based Purchasing Total Performance Score (0-100), from outcomes, safety, patient experience and efficiency. It sets a Medicare bonus or penalty..
- Net Medicare quality adjustment
- Approximate combined change to the hospital's Medicare inpatient payments from the three pay-for-performance programs, added together: the readmissions penalty, the value-based purchasing bonus or penalty, and the 1% cut for hospital-acquired conditions. Inpatient prospective payment system hospitals only; Maryland hospitals are exempt..
- Readmissions penalty
- Change to Medicare payments under the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program, which cuts payments (by up to 3%) to hospitals with more readmissions than expected. 0% means no penalty..
- Hospital-acquired condition score
- Total score in the Hospital-Acquired Condition Reduction Program, from patient safety events and infections (weighted z-scores; 0 is about average, higher is worse). Medicare cuts payments 1% for the worst-scoring quarter of hospitals..
- Value-based purchasing adjustment
- Change to Medicare payments under Hospital Value-Based Purchasing: a bonus (positive) or penalty (negative, up to 2%) based on the Total Performance Score..