Skip to main content
Hospital rankings

Hospitals in Wisconsin with the highest value-based purchasing score

54 Wisconsin hospitals ranked by value-based purchasing score in the 2026 Medicare (CMS) data. Leading: Aurora Medical Center Washington County, Sauk Prairie Hospital, Aurora Medical Center Sheboygan County. Filter by type, ownership and size, choose the measures you care about, and sort by any column.

Hospital type
All types
Hospital type
Ownership
Any ownership
Ownership
Choose columns
Overall
Patient experience
Outcomes
Safety
Timely care
Effective care
Cost
Medicare penalties
Capacity
Clear filters

54 hospitals ranked in Wisconsin by value-based purchasing score; 86 more match but have no reported value.

Compare top 4 Download CSV
Hospital rankings, page 1 of 2. Columns can be sorted.
#HospitalValue-based purchasing scorehigher is betterOverall star ratinghigher is betterPatient survey star ratinghigher is betterHeart attack death ratelower is betterHeart failure death ratelower is betterHospital-wide readmission ratelower is better · 2025 dataSerious complicationslower is betterTime in emergency departmentlower is betterMedicare spending per patientlower is betterTotal bedsCompare
National average313.311.9%11.1%15.0%1.00162 min1.00
1Aurora Medical Center Washington CountyHartford, WI · Acute care67, 99th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile—10.9%, 52nd percentile15.7%, 13th percentile0.95, 55th percentile127 min, 68th percentile0.84, 96th percentile71Compare Aurora Medical Center Washington County
2Sauk Prairie HospitalPrairie Du Sac, WI · Acute care66, 99th percentile5, 94th percentile5, 97th percentile—13.0%, 15th percentile14.1%, 91st percentile1.01, 33rd percentile152 min, 48th percentile0.86, 94th percentile36Compare Sauk Prairie Hospital
3Aurora Medical Center Sheboygan CountySheboygan, WI · Acute care66, 99th percentile5, 94th percentile4, 76th percentile11.8%, 49th percentile10.4%, 62nd percentile14.4%, 83rd percentile0.87, 81st percentile173 min, 34th percentile0.83, 97th percentile185Compare Aurora Medical Center Sheboygan County
4Aurora Medical CenterGrafton, WI · Acute care65, 99th percentile5, 94th percentile4, 76th percentile11.4%, 65th percentile9.1%, 85th percentile14.7%, 68th percentile1.05, 26th percentile188 min, 25th percentile0.85, 95th percentile62Compare Aurora Medical Center
5Aspirus Divine Savior HospitalPortage, WI · Acute care62, 98th percentile3, 43rd percentile3, 39th percentile—15.3%, 3rd percentile14.6%, 74th percentile0.96, 51st percentile153 min, 47th percentile0.81, 98th percentile73Compare Aspirus Divine Savior Hospital
6Aurora Medical Center Manitowoc CountyTwo Rivers, WI · Acute care62, 98th percentile5, 94th percentile4, 76th percentile—12.0%, 30th percentile14.8%, 61st percentile0.95, 55th percentile112 min, 81st percentile0.85, 95th percentile69Compare Aurora Medical Center Manitowoc County
7Mile Bluff Medical CenterMauston, WI · Acute care58, 97th percentile4, 73rd percentile5, 97th percentile—11.7%, 35th percentile14.5%, 79th percentile0.97, 46th percentile124 min, 71st percentile0.78, 99th percentile40Compare Mile Bluff Medical Center
8Mayo Clinic Health System-Franciscan Medical Center IncLa Crosse, WI · Acute care58, 97th percentile5, 94th percentile5, 97th percentile9.8%, 97th percentile10.2%, 66th percentile14.3%, 86th percentile0.85, 85th percentile134 min, 62nd percentile0.90, 88th percentile345Compare Mayo Clinic Health System-Franciscan Medical Center Inc
9SSM Health St Agnes Hospital-Fond Du LacFond Du Lac, WI · Acute care57, 97th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile10.8%, 83rd percentile15.5%, 2nd percentile15.0%, 46th percentile1.06, 25th percentile150 min, 49th percentile0.88, 92nd percentile151Compare SSM Health St Agnes Hospital-Fond Du Lac
10SSM Health St Clare Hospital - BarabooBaraboo, WI · Acute care56, 97th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile—11.1%, 48th percentile14.0%, 93rd percentile0.98, 41st percentile114 min, 79th percentile0.84, 96th percentile100Compare SSM Health St Clare Hospital - Baraboo
11The Monroe ClinicMonroe, WI · Acute care55, 96th percentile5, 94th percentile4, 76th percentile10.8%, 83rd percentile10.5%, 60th percentile15.6%, 16th percentile0.93, 63rd percentile145 min, 52nd percentile0.90, 88th percentile100Compare The Monroe Clinic
12Aurora Medical Center OshkoshOshkosh, WI · Acute care54, 96th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile10.9%, 80th percentile11.0%, 50th percentile14.3%, 86th percentile0.82, 90th percentile122 min, 72nd percentile0.81, 98th percentile84Compare Aurora Medical Center Oshkosh
13Marshfield Medical Center - MinocquaMinocqua, WI · Acute care53, 96th percentile5, 94th percentile5, 97th percentile—9.9%, 72nd percentile15.2%, 34th percentile0.89, 75th percentile174 min, 33rd percentile0.92, 83rd percentile19Compare Marshfield Medical Center - Minocqua
14Aurora Lakeland Medical CenterElkhorn, WI · Acute care52, 95th percentile5, 94th percentile4, 76th percentile—11.9%, 32nd percentile14.9%, 54th percentile0.89, 75th percentile145 min, 52nd percentile0.84, 96th percentile99Compare Aurora Lakeland Medical Center
15Aurora Memorial Hospital BurlingtonBurlington, WI · Acute care50, 94th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile—11.1%, 48th percentile15.2%, 34th percentile0.95, 55th percentile182 min, 28th percentile0.87, 93rd percentile123Compare Aurora Memorial Hospital Burlington
16Holy Family MemorialManitowoc, WI · Acute care48, 91st percentile3, 43rd percentile4, 76th percentile—14.2%, 7th percentile14.6%, 74th percentile0.94, 59th percentile138 min, 58th percentile0.88, 92nd percentile167Compare Holy Family Memorial
17Aurora Medical Center Bay AreaMarinette, WI · Acute care48, 91st percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile—9.3%, 82nd percentile15.7%, 13th percentile0.90, 73rd percentile129 min, 66th percentile0.84, 96th percentile99Compare Aurora Medical Center Bay Area
18Howard Young Medical CenterWoodruff, WI · Acute care47, 90th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile—13.5%, 11th percentile14.6%, 74th percentile—163 min, 40th percentile0.94, 76th percentile109Compare Howard Young Medical Center
19Marshfield Medical Center - Rice LakeRice Lake, WI · Acute care47, 90th percentile2, 17th percentile4, 76th percentile—9.3%, 82nd percentile14.7%, 68th percentile1.13, 16th percentile168 min, 37th percentile0.86, 94th percentile75Compare Marshfield Medical Center - Rice Lake
20Aurora Medical Center - SummitSummit, WI · Acute care46, 90th percentile5, 94th percentile4, 76th percentile12.0%, 42nd percentile11.1%, 48th percentile14.7%, 68th percentile0.93, 63rd percentile142 min, 55th percentile0.90, 88th percentile66Compare Aurora Medical Center - Summit
21UnityPoint Health - MeriterMadison, WI · Acute care46, 90th percentile5, 94th percentile4, 76th percentile11.0%, 77th percentile10.4%, 62nd percentile15.8%, 11th percentile0.83, 89th percentile142 min, 55th percentile0.93, 80th percentile448Compare UnityPoint Health - Meriter
22Aspirus Stevens Point Hospital & Clinics, Inc.Stevens Point, WI · Acute care46, 89th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile—13.8%, 9th percentile15.4%, 23rd percentile1.16, 13th percentile148 min, 50th percentile0.91, 86th percentile181Compare Aspirus Stevens Point Hospital & Clinics, Inc.
23Community Memorial HospitalMenomonee Falls, WI · Acute care44, 87th percentile4, 73rd percentile3, 39th percentile10.8%, 83rd percentile11.9%, 32nd percentile14.6%, 74th percentile0.85, 85th percentile219 min, 12th percentile0.91, 86th percentile237Compare Community Memorial Hospital
24Watertown Memorial HospitalWatertown, WI · Acute care43, 86th percentile3, 43rd percentile4, 76th percentile13.2%, 11th percentile21.9%, 0th percentile14.3%, 86th percentile0.91, 70th percentile120 min, 74th percentile0.97, 61st percentile95Compare Watertown Memorial Hospital
25Marshfield Medical Center - WestonWeston, WI · Acute care43, 86th percentile3, 43rd percentile4, 76th percentile12.3%, 32nd percentile11.5%, 39th percentile15.4%, 23rd percentile1.15, 14th percentile143 min, 54th percentile0.93, 80th percentile86Compare Marshfield Medical Center - Weston
26Mayo Clinic Health System Eau Claire HospitalEau Claire, WI · Acute care43, 85th percentile5, 94th percentile4, 76th percentile10.3%, 92nd percentile12.0%, 30th percentile13.6%, 97th percentile0.68, 99th percentile178 min, 31st percentile0.95, 71st percentile304Compare Mayo Clinic Health System Eau Claire Hospital
27Fort Memorial HospitalFort Atkinson, WI · Acute care42, 84th percentile4, 73rd percentile3, 39th percentile—13.4%, 12th percentile14.7%, 68th percentile0.97, 46th percentile171 min, 35th percentile0.92, 83rd percentile82Compare Fort Memorial Hospital
T28St Nicholas HospitalSheboygan, WI · Acute care41, 81st percentile3, 43rd percentile4, 76th percentile—11.5%, 39th percentile14.8%, 61st percentile0.93, 63rd percentile122 min, 72nd percentile0.87, 93rd percentile185Compare St Nicholas Hospital
T28Marshfield Medical Center - Beaver Dam (MMC-BD)Beaver Dam, WI · Acute care41, 81st percentile2, 17th percentile3, 39th percentile—15.6%, 2nd percentile14.9%, 54th percentile0.95, 55th percentile183 min, 28th percentile0.86, 94th percentile125Compare Marshfield Medical Center - Beaver Dam (MMC-BD)
30Aspirus Rhinelander HospitalRhinelander, WI · Acute care40, 81st percentile3, 43rd percentile4, 76th percentile—17.0%, 1st percentile14.4%, 83rd percentile1.03, 29th percentile162 min, 41st percentile0.89, 90th percentile99Compare Aspirus Rhinelander Hospital
T31Aurora BayCare Medical CenterGreen Bay, WI · Acute care40, 80th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile12.2%, 35th percentile12.8%, 18th percentile14.9%, 54th percentile1.01, 33rd percentile133 min, 62nd percentile0.92, 83rd percentile132Compare Aurora BayCare Medical Center
T31Bellin Memorial HospitalGreen Bay, WI · Acute care40, 80th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile11.5%, 62nd percentile15.1%, 3rd percentile14.2%, 89th percentile1.30, 6th percentile151 min, 48th percentile0.94, 76th percentile242Compare Bellin Memorial Hospital
T31Froedtert Memorial Lutheran HospitalMilwaukee, WI · Acute care40, 80th percentile3, 43rd percentile4, 76th percentile10.7%, 85th percentile9.5%, 79th percentile15.4%, 23rd percentile0.78, 95th percentile275 min, 2nd percentile0.96, 66th percentile596Compare Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital
34Thedacare Regional Medical Center - Appleton IncAppleton, WI · Acute care40, 79th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile11.9%, 46th percentile17.5%, 0th percentile13.1%, 99th percentile1.54, 2nd percentile147 min, 51st percentile0.92, 83rd percentile160Compare Thedacare Regional Medical Center - Appleton Inc
35SSM Health St Mary's Hospital - JanesvilleJanesville, WI · Acute care40, 79th percentile4, 73rd percentile3, 39th percentile—13.7%, 10th percentile14.0%, 93rd percentile0.88, 78th percentile138 min, 58th percentile0.90, 88th percentile50Compare SSM Health St Mary's Hospital - Janesville
36University Of Wisconsin Hospitals & Clinics AuthorityMadison, WI · Acute care39, 79th percentile5, 94th percentile4, 76th percentile11.6%, 58th percentile8.5%, 91st percentile14.2%, 89th percentile1.04, 28th percentile214 min, 13th percentile0.93, 80th percentile536Compare University Of Wisconsin Hospitals & Clinics Authority
37Aspirus Riverview Hospital & Clinics IncWisconsin Rapids, WI · Acute care39, 78th percentile3, 43rd percentile4, 76th percentile—12.5%, 22nd percentile15.1%, 40th percentile0.90, 73rd percentile162 min, 41st percentile0.93, 80th percentile99Compare Aspirus Riverview Hospital & Clinics Inc
38St Josephs Community Hospital West BendWest Bend, WI · Acute care39, 77th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile—12.4%, 23rd percentile14.1%, 91st percentile1.16, 13th percentile211 min, 14th percentile0.92, 83rd percentile121Compare St Josephs Community Hospital West Bend
39Beloit Health SystemBeloit, WI · Acute care38, 76th percentile3, 43rd percentile3, 39th percentile10.9%, 80th percentile14.1%, 7th percentile15.5%, 19th percentile1.29, 7th percentile129 min, 66th percentile0.96, 66th percentile256Compare Beloit Health System
T40Thedacare Regional Medical Center - NeenahNeenah, WI · Acute care35, 69th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile12.1%, 38th percentile14.1%, 7th percentile14.8%, 61st percentile1.08, 22nd percentile142 min, 55th percentile0.95, 71st percentile182Compare Thedacare Regional Medical Center - Neenah
T40West Allis Memorial HospitalWest Allis, WI · Acute care35, 69th percentile4, 73rd percentile3, 39th percentile12.2%, 35th percentile10.2%, 66th percentile15.3%, 28th percentile1.03, 29th percentile182 min, 28th percentile0.89, 90th percentile149Compare West Allis Memorial Hospital
42SSM Health St Mary's Hospital - MadisonMadison, WI · Acute care34, 67th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile10.3%, 92nd percentile14.5%, 5th percentile14.4%, 83rd percentile0.90, 73rd percentile190 min, 24th percentile0.93, 80th percentile440Compare SSM Health St Mary's Hospital - Madison
43Oconomowoc Memorial HospitalOconomowoc, WI · Acute care34, 66th percentile5, 94th percentile4, 76th percentile11.6%, 58th percentile11.7%, 35th percentile15.0%, 46th percentile0.88, 78th percentile136 min, 60th percentile1.05, 19th percentile156Compare Oconomowoc Memorial Hospital
44Aurora Medical Center KenoshaKenosha, WI · Acute care34, 66th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile11.7%, 54th percentile10.1%, 68th percentile14.4%, 83rd percentile1.20, 10th percentile179 min, 30th percentile0.94, 76th percentile74Compare Aurora Medical Center Kenosha
45Aurora St Lukes Medical CenterMilwaukee, WI · Acute care33, 65th percentile4, 73rd percentile3, 39th percentile10.9%, 80th percentile10.1%, 68th percentile15.4%, 23rd percentile1.09, 20th percentile172 min, 34th percentile0.96, 66th percentile1,213Compare Aurora St Lukes Medical Center
46Mercy Health System CorpJanesville, WI · Acute care33, 64th percentile3, 43rd percentile3, 39th percentile13.3%, 10th percentile9.2%, 84th percentile15.1%, 40th percentile1.16, 13th percentile161 min, 41st percentile0.92, 83rd percentile240Compare Mercy Health System Corp
47Aspirus Wausau HospitalWausau, WI · Acute care32, 61st percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile11.8%, 49th percentile11.8%, 34th percentile14.1%, 91st percentile0.97, 46th percentile157 min, 44th percentile0.95, 71st percentile321Compare Aspirus Wausau Hospital
48Waukesha Memorial HospitalWaukesha, WI · Acute care30, 52nd percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile12.4%, 29th percentile10.6%, 58th percentile15.5%, 19th percentile0.90, 73rd percentile140 min, 56th percentile1.05, 19th percentile400Compare Waukesha Memorial Hospital
T49Gundersen Lutheran Medical CenterLa Crosse, WI · Acute care29, 47th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile12.6%, 23rd percentile12.8%, 18th percentile13.9%, 94th percentile1.05, 26th percentile167 min, 37th percentile1.07, 14th percentile325Compare Gundersen Lutheran Medical Center
T49Marshfield Medical Center - Eau ClaireEau Claire, WI · Acute care29, 47th percentile3, 43rd percentile4, 76th percentile10.7%, 85th percentile12.2%, 27th percentile14.1%, 91st percentile1.07, 23rd percentile192 min, 23rd percentile0.91, 86th percentile44Compare Marshfield Medical Center - Eau Claire

About these rankings

Rankings use the 2026 release of CMS Care Compare data. Hospitals share a rank (“T”) when their values are equal, and only hospitals with a reported value for the sorted measure are ranked. Shading compares each value with every hospital in the country, so it doesn’t change with your filters. Small differences are often not statistically meaningful; use the methodology and glossary for context.

Value-based purchasing score
Hospital Value-Based Purchasing Total Performance Score (0-100), from outcomes, safety, patient experience and efficiency. It sets a Medicare bonus or penalty..
Overall star rating
CMS overall hospital quality star rating (1-5).
Patient survey star rating
HCAHPS summary star rating (1-5).
Heart attack death rate
30-day death rate for heart attack patients.
Heart failure death rate
30-day death rate for heart failure patients.
Hospital-wide readmission rate
Rate of unplanned readmission within 30 days, all conditions. From 2025 CMS reports the Hybrid Hospital-Wide Readmission measure (claims plus EHR data), which replaced the claims-only measure; values are close but not strictly comparable across the change. CMS suppressed it for 2026.. Latest available: 2025 release.
Serious complications
Patient safety and adverse events composite (PSI 90; 1.0 = national value).
Time in emergency department
Median time patients spent in the emergency department before leaving.
Medicare spending per patient
Medicare spending per beneficiary episode relative to the national median (1.0 = national median).
Total beds
Total beds reported to CMS (Provider of Services file).