Skip to main content
Hospital rankings

Hospitals in New York with the highest value-based purchasing score

113 New York hospitals ranked by value-based purchasing score in the 2026 Medicare (CMS) data. Filter by type, ownership and size, choose the measures you care about, and sort by any column.

Hospital type
All types
Hospital type
Ownership
Any ownership
Ownership
Choose columns
Overall
Patient experience
Outcomes
Safety
Timely care
Effective care
Cost
Medicare penalties
Capacity
Clear filters

113 hospitals ranked in New York by value-based purchasing score; 79 more match but have no reported value.

Compare top 4 Download CSV
Hospital rankings, page 2 of 3. Columns can be sorted.
#HospitalValue-based purchasing scorehigher is betterNet Medicare quality adjustmenthigher is betterReadmissions penaltyhigher is betterHospital-acquired condition scorelower is betterValue-based purchasing adjustmenthigher is betterCompare
National average31−0.48%−0.34%0.00+0.13%
51Montefiore Medical CenterBronx, NY · Acute care30, 52nd percentile−1.19%, 22nd percentile−0.26%, 43rd percentile+0.70, 13th percentile+0.07%, 52nd percentileCompare Montefiore Medical Center
52South Brooklyn HealthBrooklyn, NY · Acute care30, 52nd percentile−1.46%, 16th percentile−1.53%, 2nd percentile−0.20, 62nd percentile+0.07%, 52nd percentileCompare South Brooklyn Health
53St Joseph's Hospital Health CenterSyracuse, NY · Acute care30, 52nd percentile−2.09%, 7th percentile−2.15%, 1st percentile+0.04, 45th percentile+0.06%, 51st percentileCompare St Joseph's Hospital Health Center
54St James HospitalHornell, NY · Acute care30, 51st percentile−0.56%, 45th percentile−0.61%, 19th percentile−0.78, 91st percentile+0.05%, 51st percentileCompare St James Hospital
55Mount St. Mary's Hospital & Health CenterLewiston, NY · Acute care30, 50th percentile−0.72%, 39th percentile−0.76%, 14th percentile−1.06, 97th percentile+0.04%, 50th percentileCompare Mount St. Mary's Hospital & Health Center
56Rochester General HospitalRochester, NY · Acute care29, 49th percentile−1.42%, 17th percentile−0.44%, 28th percentile+0.79, 10th percentile+0.02%, 49th percentileCompare Rochester General Hospital
57Mount Sinai WestNew York, NY · Acute care29, 49th percentile−0.70%, 39th percentile−0.71%, 15th percentile−0.20, 62nd percentile+0.01%, 49th percentileCompare Mount Sinai West
58Peconic Bay Medical CenterRiverhead, NY · Acute care29, 49th percentile−0.38%, 51st percentile−0.38%, 33rd percentile−0.18, 60th percentile0.00%, 49th percentileCompare Peconic Bay Medical Center
59Glens Falls HospitalGlens Falls, NY · Acute care29, 48th percentile−0.12%, 61st percentile−0.09%, 62nd percentile+0.25, 32nd percentile−0.03%, 47th percentileCompare Glens Falls Hospital
60Mount Sinai HospitalNew York, NY · Acute care28, 45th percentile−0.11%, 62nd percentile−0.04%, 71st percentile+0.23, 33rd percentile−0.07%, 45th percentileCompare Mount Sinai Hospital
61Bronxcare Hospital CenterBronx, NY · Acute care28, 45th percentile−0.43%, 49th percentile−0.36%, 34th percentile+0.18, 37th percentile−0.07%, 45th percentileCompare Bronxcare Hospital Center
62Maimonides Medical CenterBrooklyn, NY · Acute care28, 44th percentile−2.97%, 1st percentile−1.89%, 1st percentile+0.55, 18th percentile−0.08%, 44th percentileCompare Maimonides Medical Center
T63Putnam Hospital CenterCarmel, NY · Acute care28, 44th percentile−0.13%, 61st percentile−0.04%, 71st percentile+0.32, 28th percentile−0.09%, 44th percentileCompare Putnam Hospital Center
T63Niagara Falls Memorial Medical CenterNiagara Falls, NY · Acute care28, 44th percentile−1.29%, 20th percentile−0.20%, 49th percentile+0.47, 21st percentile−0.09%, 44th percentileCompare Niagara Falls Memorial Medical Center
65Long Island Jewish Medical CenterNew Hyde Park, NY · Acute care28, 43rd percentile−0.45%, 48th percentile−0.35%, 35th percentile−0.23, 63rd percentile−0.10%, 43rd percentileCompare Long Island Jewish Medical Center
66University Hospital S U N Y Health Science CenterSyracuse, NY · Acute care27, 42nd percentile−1.20%, 22nd percentile−0.07%, 66th percentile+0.95, 7th percentile−0.13%, 41st percentileCompare University Hospital S U N Y Health Science Center
67Phelps HospitalSleepy Hollow, NY · Acute care27, 41st percentile−0.14%, 60th percentile0.00%, 89th percentile−0.88, 94th percentile−0.14%, 41st percentileCompare Phelps Hospital
68Mount Sinai South NassauOceanside, NY · Acute care27, 41st percentile−1.51%, 15th percentile−1.36%, 4th percentile−0.57, 83rd percentile−0.15%, 41st percentileCompare Mount Sinai South Nassau
69Good Samaritan Hospital Of SuffernSuffern, NY · Acute care27, 40th percentile−1.48%, 16th percentile−1.31%, 4th percentile−0.58, 84th percentile−0.17%, 40th percentileCompare Good Samaritan Hospital Of Suffern
70Metropolitan Hospital CenterNew York, NY · Acute care26, 39th percentile−0.18%, 59th percentile0.00%, 89th percentile−0.97, 96th percentile−0.18%, 39th percentileCompare Metropolitan Hospital Center
71Good Samaritan Hospital Medical CenterWest Islip, NY · Acute care26, 39th percentile−0.27%, 56th percentile−0.08%, 64th percentile−0.04, 50th percentile−0.19%, 38th percentileCompare Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center
72St Joseph HospitalBethpage, NY · Acute care26, 37th percentile−0.43%, 49th percentile−0.21%, 48th percentile+0.24, 32nd percentile−0.22%, 37th percentileCompare St Joseph Hospital
73Staten Island University HospitalStaten Island, NY · Acute care26, 37th percentile−0.39%, 51st percentile−0.17%, 52nd percentile+0.19, 36th percentile−0.22%, 37th percentileCompare Staten Island University Hospital
74Olean General HospitalOlean, NY · Acute care26, 36th percentile−0.40%, 50th percentile−0.17%, 52nd percentile+0.30, 30th percentile−0.23%, 36th percentileCompare Olean General Hospital
75Jamaica Hospital Medical CenterJamaica, NY · Acute care26, 36th percentile−1.70%, 12th percentile−0.47%, 26th percentile+0.47, 21st percentile−0.23%, 36th percentileCompare Jamaica Hospital Medical Center
76Queens Hospital CenterJamaica, NY · Acute care25, 34th percentile−0.62%, 42nd percentile−0.34%, 36th percentile−0.33, 70th percentile−0.28%, 34th percentileCompare Queens Hospital Center
77Arnot Ogden Medical CenterElmira, NY · Acute care25, 33rd percentile−1.61%, 13th percentile−0.32%, 38th percentile+0.87, 9th percentile−0.29%, 33rd percentileCompare Arnot Ogden Medical Center
78Bon Secours Community HospitalPort Jervis, NY · Acute care24, 32nd percentile−2.03%, 7th percentile−0.71%, 15th percentile+0.42, 23rd percentile−0.32%, 32nd percentileCompare Bon Secours Community Hospital
T79Southside HospitalBay Shore, NY · Acute care24, 32nd percentile−0.68%, 40th percentile−0.36%, 34th percentile−0.33, 69th percentile−0.32%, 32nd percentileCompare Southside Hospital
T79Crouse HospitalSyracuse, NY · Acute care24, 32nd percentile−0.91%, 33rd percentile−0.59%, 20th percentile+0.06, 43rd percentile−0.32%, 32nd percentileCompare Crouse Hospital
81Brooks-TLC Hospital System, IncDunkirk, NY · Acute care24, 31st percentile−1.39%, 18th percentile−0.04%, 71st percentile+1.03, 6th percentile−0.34%, 31st percentileCompare Brooks-TLC Hospital System, Inc
82Nyack HospitalNyack, NY · Acute care24, 30th percentile−1.80%, 10th percentile−1.44%, 3rd percentile+0.02, 46th percentile−0.36%, 30th percentileCompare Nyack Hospital
83Brooklyn Hospital Center - Downtown CampusBrooklyn, NY · Acute care24, 30th percentile−0.80%, 36th percentile−0.43%, 29th percentile−0.02, 48th percentile−0.37%, 30th percentileCompare Brooklyn Hospital Center - Downtown Campus
84Flushing Hospital Medical CenterFlushing, NY · Acute care23, 27th percentile−0.45%, 49th percentile−0.02%, 75th percentile0.00, 47th percentile−0.43%, 27th percentileCompare Flushing Hospital Medical Center
85Mercy Hospital Of BuffaloBuffalo, NY · Acute care22, 24th percentile−0.99%, 30th percentile−0.52%, 23rd percentile−0.34, 71st percentile−0.47%, 24th percentileCompare Mercy Hospital Of Buffalo
86Garnet Health Medical Center CatskillsHarris, NY · Acute care21, 21st percentile−1.59%, 14th percentile−0.05%, 69th percentile+1.49, 2nd percentile−0.54%, 21st percentileCompare Garnet Health Medical Center Catskills
T87St John's Riverside HospitalYonkers, NY · Acute care21, 19th percentile−2.17%, 6th percentile−0.60%, 19th percentile+0.45, 22nd percentile−0.57%, 19th percentileCompare St John's Riverside Hospital
T87Wyckoff Heights Medical CenterBrooklyn, NY · Acute care21, 19th percentile−1.57%, 14th percentile0.00%, 89th percentile+0.49, 20th percentile−0.57%, 19th percentileCompare Wyckoff Heights Medical Center
89Bassett HealthcareCooperstown, NY · Acute care21, 19th percentile−1.57%, 14th percentile0.00%, 89th percentile+0.59, 16th percentile−0.57%, 18th percentileCompare Bassett Healthcare
90SUNY/Downstate University Hospital Of BrooklynBrooklyn, NY · Acute care21, 18th percentile−1.91%, 9th percentile−0.33%, 37th percentile+0.45, 22nd percentile−0.58%, 18th percentileCompare SUNY/Downstate University Hospital Of Brooklyn
91Oswego HospitalOswego, NY · Acute care20, 18th percentile−1.42%, 17th percentile−0.83%, 12th percentile+0.37, 26th percentile−0.59%, 18th percentileCompare Oswego Hospital
92Richmond University Medical CenterStaten Island, NY · Acute care20, 17th percentile−2.73%, 2nd percentile−1.13%, 6th percentile+0.90, 8th percentile−0.60%, 17th percentileCompare Richmond University Medical Center
93Erie County Medical CenterBuffalo, NY · Acute care20, 17th percentile−1.68%, 12th percentile−0.06%, 67th percentile+0.54, 18th percentile−0.62%, 17th percentileCompare Erie County Medical Center
94The University Of Vermont Health Network - ChamplPlattsburgh, NY · Acute care20, 15th percentile−2.01%, 8th percentile−0.37%, 33rd percentile+1.07, 5th percentile−0.64%, 15th percentileCompare The University Of Vermont Health Network - Champl
95Montefiore St Luke's CornwallNewburgh, NY · Acute care19, 14th percentile−2.36%, 4th percentile−0.68%, 16th percentile+0.72, 12th percentile−0.68%, 14th percentileCompare Montefiore St Luke's Cornwall
T96St Peter's HospitalAlbany, NY · Acute care19, 12th percentile−1.72%, 11th percentile−1.01%, 8th percentile+0.36, 26th percentile−0.71%, 12th percentileCompare St Peter's Hospital
T96HealthAlliance Hospital Marys Avenue CampusKingston, NY · Acute care19, 12th percentile−0.94%, 32nd percentile−0.23%, 45th percentile+0.12, 40th percentile−0.71%, 12th percentileCompare HealthAlliance Hospital Marys Avenue Campus
98United Health Services Hospitals, IncBinghamton, NY · Acute care19, 12th percentile−1.83%, 10th percentile−0.12%, 58th percentile+0.85, 9th percentile−0.71%, 12th percentileCompare United Health Services Hospitals, Inc
99Cayuga Medical Center At IthacaIthaca, NY · Acute care18, 11th percentile−0.74%, 38th percentile0.00%, 89th percentile+0.15, 39th percentile−0.74%, 11th percentileCompare Cayuga Medical Center At Ithaca
100Elmhurst Hospital CenterElmhurst, NY · Acute care18, 11th percentile−0.75%, 37th percentile−0.01%, 77th percentile+0.23, 34th percentile−0.74%, 11th percentileCompare Elmhurst Hospital Center

About these rankings

Rankings use the 2026 release of CMS Care Compare data. Hospitals share a rank (“T”) when their values are equal, and only hospitals with a reported value for the sorted measure are ranked. Shading compares each value with every hospital in the country, so it doesn’t change with your filters. Small differences are often not statistically meaningful; use the methodology and glossary for context.

Value-based purchasing score
Hospital Value-Based Purchasing Total Performance Score (0-100), from outcomes, safety, patient experience and efficiency. It sets a Medicare bonus or penalty..
Net Medicare quality adjustment
Approximate combined change to the hospital's Medicare inpatient payments from the three pay-for-performance programs, added together: the readmissions penalty, the value-based purchasing bonus or penalty, and the 1% cut for hospital-acquired conditions. Inpatient prospective payment system hospitals only; Maryland hospitals are exempt..
Readmissions penalty
Change to Medicare payments under the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program, which cuts payments (by up to 3%) to hospitals with more readmissions than expected. 0% means no penalty..
Hospital-acquired condition score
Total score in the Hospital-Acquired Condition Reduction Program, from patient safety events and infections (weighted z-scores; 0 is about average, higher is worse). Medicare cuts payments 1% for the worst-scoring quarter of hospitals..
Value-based purchasing adjustment
Change to Medicare payments under Hospital Value-Based Purchasing: a bonus (positive) or penalty (negative, up to 2%) based on the Total Performance Score..