Skip to main content
Hospital rankings

Hospitals in New York with the smallest Medicare readmissions penalties

125 New York hospitals ranked by readmissions penalty in the 2026 Medicare (CMS) data. Leading: Hospital For Special Surgery, Hudson Valley Hospital Center, Mercy Medical Center. Filter by type, ownership and size, choose the measures you care about, and sort by any column.

Hospital type
All types
Hospital type
Ownership
Any ownership
Ownership
Choose columns
Overall
Patient experience
Outcomes
Safety
Timely care
Effective care
Cost
Medicare penalties
Capacity
Clear filters

125 hospitals ranked in New York by readmissions penalty; 67 more match but have no reported value.

Compare top 4 Download CSV
Hospital rankings, page 1 of 3. Columns can be sorted.
#HospitalReadmissions penaltyhigher is betterOverall star ratinghigher is betterPatient survey star ratinghigher is betterHeart attack death ratelower is betterHeart failure death ratelower is betterHospital-wide readmission ratelower is better · 2025 dataSerious complicationslower is betterTime in emergency departmentlower is betterMedicare spending per patientlower is betterTotal bedsCompare
National average−0.34%3.311.9%11.1%15.0%1.00162 min1.00
T1Hospital For Special SurgeryNew York, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile5, 94th percentile4, 76th percentile——11.9%, 100th percentile0.62, 100th percentile—0.92, 83rd percentile205Compare Hospital For Special Surgery
T1Hudson Valley Hospital CenterCortlandt Manor, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile5, 94th percentile4, 76th percentile10.8%, 83rd percentile11.3%, 44th percentile14.2%, 89th percentile0.96, 51st percentile202 min, 18th percentile1.06, 16th percentile128Compare Hudson Valley Hospital Center
T1Mercy Medical CenterRockville Centre, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile5, 94th percentile3, 39th percentile10.1%, 95th percentile11.3%, 44th percentile13.7%, 97th percentile0.86, 83rd percentile238 min, 7th percentile1.14, 4th percentile375Compare Mercy Medical Center
T1NYU Langone HospitalsNew York, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile5, 94th percentile3, 39th percentile6.7%, 100th percentile5.2%, 100th percentile13.1%, 99th percentile0.67, 99th percentile203 min, 18th percentile0.99, 50th percentile1,069Compare NYU Langone Hospitals
T1New York-Presbyterian HospitalNew York, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile5, 94th percentile3, 39th percentile9.6%, 98th percentile6.9%, 99th percentile13.6%, 97th percentile0.40, 100th percentile224 min, 10th percentile0.99, 50th percentile2,262Compare New York-Presbyterian Hospital
T1New York-Presbyterian/QueensFlushing, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile5, 94th percentile3, 39th percentile10.7%, 85th percentile6.9%, 99th percentile13.6%, 97th percentile0.62, 100th percentile280 min, 2nd percentile1.08, 12th percentile535Compare New York-Presbyterian/Queens
T1St Catherine Of Siena HospitalSmithtown, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile5, 94th percentile3, 39th percentile9.8%, 97th percentile9.5%, 79th percentile15.1%, 40th percentile0.70, 98th percentile206 min, 16th percentile1.01, 38th percentile318Compare St Catherine Of Siena Hospital
T1St Charles HospitalPort Jefferson, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile5, 94th percentile4, 76th percentile11.9%, 46th percentile10.7%, 56th percentile15.3%, 28th percentile0.89, 75th percentile228 min, 9th percentile1.07, 14th percentile231Compare St Charles Hospital
T1Jones Memorial HospitalWellsville, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile—8.2%, 93rd percentile13.5%, 98th percentile1.11, 18th percentile144 min, 53rd percentile0.93, 80th percentile49Compare Jones Memorial Hospital
T1Phelps HospitalSleepy Hollow, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile4, 73rd percentile3, 39th percentile—10.2%, 66th percentile13.8%, 96th percentile1.08, 22nd percentile202 min, 18th percentile1.03, 28th percentile235Compare Phelps Hospital
T1Cayuga Medical Center At IthacaIthaca, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile3, 43rd percentile3, 39th percentile11.2%, 71st percentile11.9%, 32nd percentile14.2%, 89th percentile0.96, 51st percentile244 min, 6th percentile1.04, 23rd percentile212Compare Cayuga Medical Center At Ithaca
T1Metropolitan Hospital CenterNew York, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile3, 43rd percentile2, 10th percentile—10.4%, 62nd percentile15.1%, 40th percentile0.93, 63rd percentile171 min, 35th percentile1.10, 8th percentile363Compare Metropolitan Hospital Center
T1Montefiore Mount Vernon HospitalMount Vernon, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile3, 43rd percentile2, 10th percentile—9.8%, 73rd percentile14.9%, 54th percentile0.97, 46th percentile195 min, 21st percentile1.21, 2nd percentile245Compare Montefiore Mount Vernon Hospital
T1Samaritan Hospital Of Troy, New YorkTroy, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile3, 43rd percentile3, 39th percentile12.1%, 38th percentile10.6%, 58th percentile14.3%, 86th percentile0.94, 59th percentile228 min, 9th percentile0.93, 80th percentile238Compare Samaritan Hospital Of Troy, New York
T1Strong Memorial HospitalRochester, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile3, 43rd percentile3, 39th percentile11.0%, 77th percentile11.5%, 39th percentile15.0%, 46th percentile1.33, 6th percentile247 min, 5th percentile0.92, 83rd percentile900Compare Strong Memorial Hospital
T1Bassett HealthcareCooperstown, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile2, 17th percentile3, 39th percentile11.4%, 65th percentile11.6%, 37th percentile15.6%, 16th percentile1.27, 7th percentile199 min, 20th percentile0.99, 50th percentile180Compare Bassett Healthcare
T1Chenango Memorial HospitalNorwich, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile2, 17th percentile4, 76th percentile—10.2%, 66th percentile14.8%, 61st percentile1.16, 13th percentile108 min, 84th percentile0.93, 80th percentile58Compare Chenango Memorial Hospital
T1Lincoln Medical & Mental Health CenterBronx, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile2, 17th percentile2, 10th percentile—8.5%, 91st percentile15.1%, 40th percentile0.94, 59th percentile234 min, 8th percentile1.01, 38th percentile586Compare Lincoln Medical & Mental Health Center
T1Wyckoff Heights Medical CenterBrooklyn, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile2, 17th percentile2, 10th percentile11.4%, 65th percentile9.6%, 77th percentile15.1%, 40th percentile0.97, 46th percentile218 min, 12th percentile1.02, 33rd percentile324Compare Wyckoff Heights Medical Center
T1Unity Specialty HospitalRochester, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile————————97Compare Unity Specialty Hospital
T1Westfield Memorial Hospital, IncWestfield, NY · Acute care0.00%, 89th percentile————14.8%, 61st percentile—120 min, 74th percentile0.86, 94th percentile—Compare Westfield Memorial Hospital, Inc
T22John T Mather Memorial Hospital Of Port JeffersonPort Jefferson, NY · Acute care−0.01%, 77th percentile5, 94th percentile4, 76th percentile10.4%, 90th percentile8.9%, 87th percentile12.2%, 100th percentile0.93, 63rd percentile235 min, 7th percentile1.02, 33rd percentile248Compare John T Mather Memorial Hospital Of Port Jefferson
T22Lenox Hill HospitalNew York, NY · Acute care−0.01%, 77th percentile5, 94th percentile2, 10th percentile12.3%, 32nd percentile8.7%, 89th percentile14.5%, 79th percentile0.96, 51st percentile184 min, 27th percentile1.03, 28th percentile652Compare Lenox Hill Hospital
T22Elmhurst Hospital CenterElmhurst, NY · Acute care−0.01%, 77th percentile2, 17th percentile2, 10th percentile11.5%, 62nd percentile8.6%, 90th percentile16.0%, 7th percentile1.13, 16th percentile278 min, 2nd percentile1.07, 14th percentile545Compare Elmhurst Hospital Center
T22Albany Medical Center HospitalAlbany, NY · Acute care−0.01%, 77th percentile1, 3rd percentile2, 10th percentile12.0%, 42nd percentile12.4%, 23rd percentile15.3%, 28th percentile1.22, 9th percentile266 min, 3rd percentile1.00, 44th percentile732Compare Albany Medical Center Hospital
T26Northwell Hospital Glen CoveGlen Cove, NY · Acute care−0.02%, 75th percentile5, 94th percentile4, 76th percentile10.4%, 90th percentile9.1%, 85th percentile15.0%, 46th percentile0.85, 85th percentile145 min, 52nd percentile1.14, 4th percentile247Compare Northwell Hospital Glen Cove
T26Flushing Hospital Medical CenterFlushing, NY · Acute care−0.02%, 75th percentile2, 17th percentile2, 10th percentile—9.2%, 84th percentile15.6%, 16th percentile1.02, 31st percentile220 min, 12th percentile1.25, 1st percentile293Compare Flushing Hospital Medical Center
T28Mount Sinai HospitalNew York, NY · Acute care−0.04%, 71st percentile4, 73rd percentile3, 39th percentile12.1%, 38th percentile6.9%, 99th percentile14.6%, 74th percentile1.03, 29th percentile248 min, 5th percentile0.98, 55th percentile1,171Compare Mount Sinai Hospital
T28Putnam Hospital CenterCarmel, NY · Acute care−0.04%, 71st percentile3, 43rd percentile4, 76th percentile—10.0%, 70th percentile14.4%, 83rd percentile0.88, 78th percentile170 min, 35th percentile1.00, 44th percentile164Compare Putnam Hospital Center
T28Brooks-TLC Hospital System, IncDunkirk, NY · Acute care−0.04%, 71st percentile1, 3rd percentile4, 76th percentile—14.3%, 6th percentile15.3%, 28th percentile0.97, 46th percentile156 min, 45th percentile0.98, 55th percentile65Compare Brooks-TLC Hospital System, Inc
T31Nicholas H Noyes Memorial HospitalDansville, NY · Acute care−0.05%, 69th percentile3, 43rd percentile3, 39th percentile—11.5%, 39th percentile15.7%, 13th percentile0.93, 63rd percentile202 min, 18th percentile0.83, 97th percentile72Compare Nicholas H Noyes Memorial Hospital
T31St Marys HealthcareAmsterdam, NY · Acute care−0.05%, 69th percentile3, 43rd percentile3, 39th percentile—9.3%, 82nd percentile15.4%, 23rd percentile1.04, 28th percentile155 min, 46th percentile1.07, 14th percentile149Compare St Marys Healthcare
T31Garnet Health Medical Center CatskillsHarris, NY · Acute care−0.05%, 69th percentile2, 17th percentile2, 10th percentile—9.2%, 84th percentile15.7%, 13th percentile0.92, 67th percentile183 min, 28th percentile0.98, 55th percentile164Compare Garnet Health Medical Center Catskills
T34St Anthony Community HospitalWarwick, NY · Acute care−0.06%, 67th percentile4, 73rd percentile4, 76th percentile11.6%, 58th percentile11.9%, 32nd percentile14.9%, 54th percentile0.92, 67th percentile162 min, 41st percentile0.94, 76th percentile60Compare St Anthony Community Hospital
T34Erie County Medical CenterBuffalo, NY · Acute care−0.06%, 67th percentile2, 17th percentile3, 39th percentile—10.1%, 68th percentile15.1%, 40th percentile2.09, 0th percentile325 min, 1st percentile0.98, 55th percentile526Compare Erie County Medical Center
T34Bertrand Chaffee HospitalSpringville, NY · Acute care−0.06%, 67th percentile—3, 39th percentile——15.2%, 34th percentile0.99, 37th percentile145 min, 52nd percentile0.82, 98th percentile49Compare Bertrand Chaffee Hospital
T37University Hospital S U N Y Health Science CenterSyracuse, NY · Acute care−0.07%, 66th percentile3, 43rd percentile3, 39th percentile12.8%, 19th percentile10.7%, 56th percentile15.5%, 19th percentile1.48, 3rd percentile291 min, 2nd percentile0.99, 50th percentile511Compare University Hospital S U N Y Health Science Center
T37Kings County Hospital CenterBrooklyn, NY · Acute care−0.07%, 66th percentile1, 3rd percentile2, 10th percentile—10.2%, 66th percentile14.9%, 54th percentile1.18, 12th percentile261 min, 4th percentile1.02, 33rd percentile639Compare Kings County Hospital Center
T37St Barnabas HospitalBronx, NY · Acute care−0.07%, 66th percentile1, 3rd percentile2, 10th percentile—11.1%, 48th percentile15.1%, 40th percentile1.28, 7th percentile301 min, 1st percentile0.98, 55th percentile446Compare St Barnabas Hospital
T40Plainview HospitalPlainview, NY · Acute care−0.08%, 64th percentile4, 73rd percentile3, 39th percentile10.0%, 96th percentile9.9%, 72nd percentile14.8%, 61st percentile0.93, 63rd percentile245 min, 6th percentile1.09, 10th percentile204Compare Plainview Hospital
T40Good Samaritan Hospital Medical CenterWest Islip, NY · Acute care−0.08%, 64th percentile3, 43rd percentile3, 39th percentile14.9%, 1st percentile11.2%, 46th percentile14.9%, 54th percentile1.43, 3rd percentile224 min, 10th percentile1.08, 12th percentile437Compare Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center
T40Bellevue Hospital CenterNew York, NY · Acute care−0.08%, 64th percentile2, 17th percentile2, 10th percentile10.2%, 93rd percentile8.8%, 88th percentile15.1%, 40th percentile1.16, 13th percentile181 min, 29th percentile0.91, 86th percentile912Compare Bellevue Hospital Center
T40Woodhull Medical & Mental Health CenterBrooklyn, NY · Acute care−0.08%, 64th percentile2, 17th percentile2, 10th percentile—8.8%, 88th percentile14.5%, 79th percentile1.40, 4th percentile198 min, 20th percentile0.98, 55th percentile411Compare Woodhull Medical & Mental Health Center
T44Adirondack Medical Center - Saranac LakeSaranac Lake, NY · Acute care−0.09%, 62nd percentile4, 73rd percentile5, 97th percentile—13.4%, 12th percentile14.3%, 86th percentile1.28, 7th percentile136 min, 60th percentile0.87, 93rd percentile95Compare Adirondack Medical Center - Saranac Lake
T44Glens Falls HospitalGlens Falls, NY · Acute care−0.09%, 62nd percentile3, 43rd percentile3, 39th percentile12.7%, 21st percentile13.5%, 11th percentile14.6%, 74th percentile1.38, 4th percentile260 min, 4th percentile0.93, 80th percentile442Compare Glens Falls Hospital
T44Wynn HospitalUtica, NY · Acute care−0.09%, 62nd percentile1, 3rd percentile2, 10th percentile12.1%, 38th percentile12.3%, 25th percentile15.6%, 16th percentile1.50, 2nd percentile211 min, 14th percentile1.08, 12th percentile372Compare Wynn Hospital
T47Nathan Littauer HospitalGloversville, NY · Acute care−0.10%, 61st percentile2, 17th percentile3, 39th percentile—12.3%, 25th percentile15.0%, 46th percentile1.27, 7th percentile169 min, 36th percentile0.85, 95th percentile74Compare Nathan Littauer Hospital
T47UPMC ChautauquaJamestown, NY · Acute care−0.10%, 61st percentile2, 17th percentile3, 39th percentile11.6%, 58th percentile11.8%, 34th percentile16.0%, 7th percentile0.89, 75th percentile171 min, 35th percentile0.96, 66th percentile95Compare UPMC Chautauqua
49St Joseph's Medical CenterYonkers, NY · Acute care−0.11%, 60th percentile1, 3rd percentile1, 1st percentile—9.8%, 73rd percentile15.2%, 34th percentile0.91, 70th percentile201 min, 19th percentile1.26, 1st percentile332Compare St Joseph's Medical Center
T50Samaritan Medical CenterWatertown, NY · Acute care−0.12%, 58th percentile2, 17th percentile3, 39th percentile—12.8%, 18th percentile15.3%, 28th percentile0.94, 59th percentile260 min, 4th percentile0.89, 90th percentile287Compare Samaritan Medical Center

About these rankings

Rankings use the 2026 release of CMS Care Compare data. Hospitals share a rank (“T”) when their values are equal, and only hospitals with a reported value for the sorted measure are ranked. Shading compares each value with every hospital in the country, so it doesn’t change with your filters. Small differences are often not statistically meaningful; use the methodology and glossary for context.

Readmissions penalty
Change to Medicare payments under the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program, which cuts payments (by up to 3%) to hospitals with more readmissions than expected. 0% means no penalty..
Overall star rating
CMS overall hospital quality star rating (1-5).
Patient survey star rating
HCAHPS summary star rating (1-5).
Heart attack death rate
30-day death rate for heart attack patients.
Heart failure death rate
30-day death rate for heart failure patients.
Hospital-wide readmission rate
Rate of unplanned readmission within 30 days, all conditions. From 2025 CMS reports the Hybrid Hospital-Wide Readmission measure (claims plus EHR data), which replaced the claims-only measure; values are close but not strictly comparable across the change. CMS suppressed it for 2026.. Latest available: 2025 release.
Serious complications
Patient safety and adverse events composite (PSI 90; 1.0 = national value).
Time in emergency department
Median time patients spent in the emergency department before leaving.
Medicare spending per patient
Medicare spending per beneficiary episode relative to the national median (1.0 = national median).
Total beds
Total beds reported to CMS (Provider of Services file).