Hospital rankings
Hospitals in Michigan with the highest value-based purchasing score
63 Michigan hospitals ranked by value-based purchasing score in the 2026 Medicare (CMS) data. Leading: UP Health System Portage, University Of Michigan Health-Sparrow Carson, Trinity Health Grand Haven Hospital. Filter by type, ownership and size, choose the measures you care about, and sort by any column.
| # | Hospital | Value-based purchasing scorehigher is better | Net Medicare quality adjustmenthigher is better | Readmissions penaltyhigher is better | Hospital-acquired condition scorelower is better | Value-based purchasing adjustmenthigher is better | Compare |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| National average | 31 | −0.48% | −0.34% | 0.00 | +0.13% | ||
| 1 | UP Health System Portage | 72, 100th percentile | +2.95%, 100th percentile | 0.00%, 89th percentile | −0.78, 90th percentile | +2.95%, 100th percentile | Compare UP Health System Portage |
| 2 | University Of Michigan Health-Sparrow Carson | 63, 99th percentile | +2.30%, 99th percentile | −0.02%, 75th percentile | −0.72, 88th percentile | +2.32%, 99th percentile | Compare University Of Michigan Health-Sparrow Carson |
| 3 | Trinity Health Grand Haven Hospital | 59, 98th percentile | +2.09%, 99th percentile | 0.00%, 89th percentile | −0.36, 71st percentile | +2.09%, 98th percentile | Compare Trinity Health Grand Haven Hospital |
| T4 | Corewell Health Zeeland Hospital | 56, 97th percentile | +1.75%, 98th percentile | −0.09%, 62nd percentile | −0.58, 84th percentile | +1.84%, 97th percentile | Compare Corewell Health Zeeland Hospital |
| T4 | Chelsea Hospital | 56, 97th percentile | +0.22%, 80th percentile | −0.62%, 18th percentile | +0.96, 7th percentile | +1.84%, 97th percentile | Compare Chelsea Hospital |
| 6 | Munson Healthcare Manistee Hospital | 54, 96th percentile | +1.64%, 98th percentile | −0.06%, 67th percentile | −0.72, 88th percentile | +1.70%, 96th percentile | Compare Munson Healthcare Manistee Hospital |
| 7 | Chippewa County War Memorial Hospital | 53, 95th percentile | −0.18%, 59th percentile | −0.80%, 12th percentile | +1.91, 1st percentile | +1.62%, 95th percentile | Compare Chippewa County War Memorial Hospital |
| 8 | Corewell Health Ludington Hospital | 52, 95th percentile | +1.57%, 97th percentile | −0.03%, 73rd percentile | −0.12, 55th percentile | +1.60%, 95th percentile | Compare Corewell Health Ludington Hospital |
| T9 | Holland Hospital | 51, 95th percentile | +0.53%, 86th percentile | 0.00%, 89th percentile | +1.06, 5th percentile | +1.53%, 95th percentile | Compare Holland Hospital |
| T9 | Hillsdale Hospital | 51, 95th percentile | +1.45%, 97th percentile | −0.08%, 64th percentile | −0.09, 53rd percentile | +1.53%, 95th percentile | Compare Hillsdale Hospital |
| 11 | Munson Healthcare Cadillac Hospital | 51, 94th percentile | +1.48%, 97th percentile | −0.03%, 73rd percentile | −0.42, 75th percentile | +1.51%, 94th percentile | Compare Munson Healthcare Cadillac Hospital |
| 12 | Munson Healthcare Otsego Memorial Hospital | 50, 94th percentile | +0.59%, 87th percentile | −0.86%, 11th percentile | −0.17, 59th percentile | +1.45%, 94th percentile | Compare Munson Healthcare Otsego Memorial Hospital |
| 13 | Oaklawn Hospital | 49, 93rd percentile | +1.31%, 96th percentile | −0.06%, 67th percentile | +0.03, 46th percentile | +1.37%, 93rd percentile | Compare Oaklawn Hospital |
| 14 | Mymichigan Medical Center Alma | 44, 87th percentile | +0.64%, 88th percentile | −0.40%, 31st percentile | −0.64, 86th percentile | +1.04%, 87th percentile | Compare Mymichigan Medical Center Alma |
| 15 | Spectrum Health United Hospital | 43, 85th percentile | +0.09%, 76th percentile | −0.85%, 11th percentile | −0.19, 61st percentile | +0.94%, 85th percentile | Compare Spectrum Health United Hospital |
| 16 | University Of Michigan Health System | 43, 85th percentile | +0.78%, 90th percentile | −0.15%, 54th percentile | +0.01, 46th percentile | +0.93%, 85th percentile | Compare University Of Michigan Health System |
| 17 | Munson Healthcare Grayling Hospital | 42, 83rd percentile | −0.12%, 61st percentile | 0.00%, 89th percentile | +1.42, 2nd percentile | +0.88%, 83rd percentile | Compare Munson Healthcare Grayling Hospital |
| 18 | Trinity Health Livingston Hospital | 41, 82nd percentile | −0.17%, 59th percentile | 0.00%, 89th percentile | +0.78, 11th percentile | +0.83%, 82nd percentile | Compare Trinity Health Livingston Hospital |
| 19 | Mymichigan Medical Center West Branch | 41, 82nd percentile | +0.64%, 88th percentile | −0.19%, 50th percentile | −0.71, 88th percentile | +0.83%, 82nd percentile | Compare Mymichigan Medical Center West Branch |
| 20 | Mymichigan Medical Center Clare | 40, 81st percentile | +0.18%, 78th percentile | −0.60%, 19th percentile | −0.19, 60th percentile | +0.78%, 81st percentile | Compare Mymichigan Medical Center Clare |
| 21 | Trinity Health Ann Arbor Hospital | 40, 80th percentile | +0.44%, 85th percentile | −0.32%, 38th percentile | +0.23, 33rd percentile | +0.76%, 80th percentile | Compare Trinity Health Ann Arbor Hospital |
| 22 | Corewell Health Big Rapids Hospital | 40, 79th percentile | −0.71%, 39th percentile | −0.44%, 28th percentile | +0.86, 9th percentile | +0.73%, 79th percentile | Compare Corewell Health Big Rapids Hospital |
| 23 | Beaumont Hospital - Grosse Pointe | 38, 76th percentile | −0.26%, 56th percentile | −0.89%, 10th percentile | −0.35, 71st percentile | +0.63%, 76th percentile | Compare Beaumont Hospital - Grosse Pointe |
| 24 | Mercy Health Saint Mary's | 37, 74th percentile | −0.53%, 46th percentile | −0.10%, 61st percentile | +0.66, 14th percentile | +0.57%, 74th percentile | Compare Mercy Health Saint Mary's |
| 25 | Henry Ford Health West Bloomfield Hospital | 36, 72nd percentile | −0.72%, 38th percentile | −1.23%, 5th percentile | −0.33, 70th percentile | +0.51%, 72nd percentile | Compare Henry Ford Health West Bloomfield Hospital |
| 26 | ProMedica Charles And Virginia Hickman Hospital | 36, 71st percentile | +0.47%, 85th percentile | 0.00%, 89th percentile | −0.15, 58th percentile | +0.47%, 71st percentile | Compare ProMedica Charles And Virginia Hickman Hospital |
| 27 | Munson Medical Center | 33, 63rd percentile | +0.22%, 79th percentile | −0.06%, 67th percentile | −0.03, 49th percentile | +0.28%, 63rd percentile | Compare Munson Medical Center |
| 28 | Insight Hospital And Medical Center Coldwater | 33, 62nd percentile | −0.35%, 53rd percentile | −0.61%, 19th percentile | −0.22, 63rd percentile | +0.26%, 62nd percentile | Compare Insight Hospital And Medical Center Coldwater |
| T29 | Henry Ford Allegiance Health | 31, 57th percentile | −0.17%, 59th percentile | −0.32%, 38th percentile | −0.55, 83rd percentile | +0.15%, 57th percentile | Compare Henry Ford Allegiance Health |
| T29 | Memorial Healthcare | 31, 57th percentile | −0.73%, 38th percentile | −0.89%, 10th percentile | −0.30, 68th percentile | +0.15%, 57th percentile | Compare Memorial Healthcare |
| 31 | Mymichigan Medical Center Midland | 31, 55th percentile | +0.05%, 75th percentile | −0.07%, 66th percentile | +0.26, 32nd percentile | +0.12%, 55th percentile | Compare Mymichigan Medical Center Midland |
| 32 | Henry Ford Health Hospital | 31, 54th percentile | −0.16%, 60th percentile | −0.26%, 43rd percentile | +0.13, 40th percentile | +0.10%, 54th percentile | Compare Henry Ford Health Hospital |
| 33 | Huron Valley-Sinai Hospital | 30, 53rd percentile | −0.87%, 34th percentile | −0.96%, 9th percentile | +0.38, 25th percentile | +0.09%, 53rd percentile | Compare Huron Valley-Sinai Hospital |
| 34 | Bronson Methodist Hospital | 30, 53rd percentile | +0.08%, 76th percentile | −0.01%, 77th percentile | −0.10, 54th percentile | +0.09%, 53rd percentile | Compare Bronson Methodist Hospital |
| 35 | Mymichigan Medical Center Alpena | 30, 52nd percentile | +0.02%, 74th percentile | −0.04%, 71st percentile | +0.31, 29th percentile | +0.06%, 51st percentile | Compare Mymichigan Medical Center Alpena |
| 36 | Dickinson County Memorial Hospital | 29, 50th percentile | −1.10%, 25th percentile | −0.13%, 56th percentile | +0.57, 17th percentile | +0.03%, 50th percentile | Compare Dickinson County Memorial Hospital |
| 37 | Spectrum Health | 29, 49th percentile | −0.02%, 66th percentile | −0.02%, 75th percentile | −0.08, 52nd percentile | 0.00%, 49th percentile | Compare Spectrum Health |
| T38 | University Of Michigan Health - West | 28, 46th percentile | −1.05%, 26th percentile | 0.00%, 89th percentile | +0.62, 15th percentile | −0.05%, 46th percentile | Compare University Of Michigan Health - West |
| T38 | UPHS Marquette DLP Hospital | 28, 46th percentile | −0.33%, 53rd percentile | −0.28%, 41st percentile | +0.20, 35th percentile | −0.05%, 46th percentile | Compare UPHS Marquette DLP Hospital |
| 40 | Henry Ford Macomb Hospital | 28, 46th percentile | −0.07%, 64th percentile | −0.01%, 77th percentile | −0.10, 54th percentile | −0.06%, 46th percentile | Compare Henry Ford Macomb Hospital |
| 41 | Bronson Battle Creek Hospital | 28, 44th percentile | −1.75%, 11th percentile | −0.66%, 17th percentile | +0.64, 15th percentile | −0.09%, 44th percentile | Compare Bronson Battle Creek Hospital |
| 42 | Lakeland Hospital, St Joseph | 26, 37th percentile | −0.37%, 52nd percentile | −0.15%, 54th percentile | −0.15, 57th percentile | −0.22%, 37th percentile | Compare Lakeland Hospital, St Joseph |
| 43 | Covenant Medical Center | 25, 33rd percentile | −1.96%, 8th percentile | −0.66%, 17th percentile | +0.51, 19th percentile | −0.30%, 33rd percentile | Compare Covenant Medical Center |
| 44 | Beaumont Hospital, Troy | 24, 32nd percentile | −1.42%, 17th percentile | −1.10%, 6th percentile | +0.38, 25th percentile | −0.32%, 32nd percentile | Compare Beaumont Hospital, Troy |
| 45 | Corewell Health Trenton Hospital | 24, 31st percentile | −1.37%, 19th percentile | −1.04%, 7th percentile | +0.31, 29th percentile | −0.33%, 31st percentile | Compare Corewell Health Trenton Hospital |
| 46 | Trinity Health Muskegon Hospital | 24, 31st percentile | −1.43%, 17th percentile | −0.08%, 64th percentile | +0.94, 7th percentile | −0.34%, 31st percentile | Compare Trinity Health Muskegon Hospital |
| 47 | Lake Huron Medical Center | 24, 30th percentile | −0.57%, 44th percentile | −0.22%, 46th percentile | −0.91, 95th percentile | −0.35%, 30th percentile | Compare Lake Huron Medical Center |
| T48 | Garden City Hospital | 23, 28th percentile | −1.53%, 15th percentile | −1.13%, 6th percentile | −0.82, 92nd percentile | −0.40%, 28th percentile | Compare Garden City Hospital |
| T48 | Hurley Medical Center | 23, 28th percentile | −0.57%, 44th percentile | −0.17%, 52nd percentile | −0.34, 71st percentile | −0.40%, 28th percentile | Compare Hurley Medical Center |
| 50 | Beaumont Hospital - Dearborn | 23, 27th percentile | −2.30%, 5th percentile | −0.88%, 11th percentile | +0.94, 7th percentile | −0.42%, 27th percentile | Compare Beaumont Hospital - Dearborn |
About these rankings
Rankings use the 2026 release of CMS Care Compare data. Hospitals share a rank (“T”) when their values are equal, and only hospitals with a reported value for the sorted measure are ranked. Shading compares each value with every hospital in the country, so it doesn’t change with your filters. Small differences are often not statistically meaningful; use the methodology and glossary for context.
- Value-based purchasing score
- Hospital Value-Based Purchasing Total Performance Score (0-100), from outcomes, safety, patient experience and efficiency. It sets a Medicare bonus or penalty..
- Net Medicare quality adjustment
- Approximate combined change to the hospital's Medicare inpatient payments from the three pay-for-performance programs, added together: the readmissions penalty, the value-based purchasing bonus or penalty, and the 1% cut for hospital-acquired conditions. Inpatient prospective payment system hospitals only; Maryland hospitals are exempt..
- Readmissions penalty
- Change to Medicare payments under the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program, which cuts payments (by up to 3%) to hospitals with more readmissions than expected. 0% means no penalty..
- Hospital-acquired condition score
- Total score in the Hospital-Acquired Condition Reduction Program, from patient safety events and infections (weighted z-scores; 0 is about average, higher is worse). Medicare cuts payments 1% for the worst-scoring quarter of hospitals..
- Value-based purchasing adjustment
- Change to Medicare payments under Hospital Value-Based Purchasing: a bonus (positive) or penalty (negative, up to 2%) based on the Total Performance Score..