Skip to main content
Hospital rankings

Hospitals in New York with the smallest Medicare readmissions penalties

125 New York hospitals ranked by readmissions penalty in the 2026 Medicare (CMS) data. Filter by type, ownership and size, choose the measures you care about, and sort by any column.

Hospital type
All types
Hospital type
Ownership
Any ownership
Ownership
Choose columns
Overall
Patient experience
Outcomes
Safety
Timely care
Effective care
Cost
Medicare penalties
Capacity
Clear filters

125 hospitals ranked in New York by readmissions penalty; 67 more match but have no reported value.

Compare top 4 Download CSV
Hospital rankings, page 3 of 3. Columns can be sorted.
#HospitalReadmissions penaltyhigher is betterNet Medicare quality adjustmenthigher is betterHospital-acquired condition scorelower is betterValue-based purchasing scorehigher is betterValue-based purchasing adjustmenthigher is betterCompare
National average−0.34%−0.48%0.0031+0.13%
T100Geneva General HospitalGeneva, NY · Acute care−0.61%, 19th percentile−0.80%, 36th percentile+0.73, 12th percentile41, 81st percentile+0.81%, 81st percentileCompare Geneva General Hospital
102Oneida Health HospitalOneida, NY · Acute care−0.67%, 17th percentile−0.36%, 52nd percentile+0.01, 47th percentile34, 65th percentile+0.31%, 65th percentileCompare Oneida Health Hospital
T103Mount Sinai Beth IsraelNew York, NY · Acute care−0.68%, 16th percentile−0.52%, 46th percentile−0.58, 84th percentile31, 57th percentile+0.16%, 57th percentileCompare Mount Sinai Beth Israel
T103Montefiore St Luke's CornwallNewburgh, NY · Acute care−0.68%, 16th percentile−2.36%, 4th percentile+0.72, 12th percentile19, 14th percentile−0.68%, 14th percentileCompare Montefiore St Luke's Cornwall
105Our Lady Of Lourdes Memorial Hospital, IncBinghamton, NY · Acute care−0.69%, 16th percentile−1.69%, 12th percentile+1.29, 3rd percentile——Compare Our Lady Of Lourdes Memorial Hospital, Inc
106Vassar Brothers Medical CenterPoughkeepsie, NY · Acute care−0.70%, 15th percentile−0.36%, 52nd percentile−0.18, 59th percentile34, 66th percentile+0.34%, 66th percentileCompare Vassar Brothers Medical Center
T107Mount Sinai WestNew York, NY · Acute care−0.71%, 15th percentile−0.70%, 39th percentile−0.20, 62nd percentile29, 49th percentile+0.01%, 49th percentileCompare Mount Sinai West
T107Bon Secours Community HospitalPort Jervis, NY · Acute care−0.71%, 15th percentile−2.03%, 7th percentile+0.42, 23rd percentile24, 32nd percentile−0.32%, 32nd percentileCompare Bon Secours Community Hospital
109Garnet Health Medical CenterMiddletown, NY · Acute care−0.73%, 15th percentile−0.57%, 44th percentile+0.12, 40th percentile31, 57th percentile+0.15%, 57th percentileCompare Garnet Health Medical Center
110F F Thompson HospitalCanandaigua, NY · Acute care−0.75%, 14th percentile−1.53%, 15th percentile+0.78, 10th percentile32, 61st percentile+0.22%, 61st percentileCompare F F Thompson Hospital
111Mount St. Mary's Hospital & Health CenterLewiston, NY · Acute care−0.76%, 14th percentile−0.72%, 39th percentile−1.06, 97th percentile30, 50th percentile+0.04%, 50th percentileCompare Mount St. Mary's Hospital & Health Center
112Oswego HospitalOswego, NY · Acute care−0.83%, 12th percentile−1.42%, 17th percentile+0.37, 26th percentile20, 18th percentile−0.59%, 18th percentileCompare Oswego Hospital
113St Peter's HospitalAlbany, NY · Acute care−1.01%, 8th percentile−1.72%, 11th percentile+0.36, 26th percentile19, 12th percentile−0.71%, 12th percentileCompare St Peter's Hospital
114Newark-Wayne Community HospitalNewark, NY · Acute care−1.03%, 7th percentile−0.63%, 42nd percentile+0.21, 34th percentile35, 69th percentile+0.40%, 69th percentileCompare Newark-Wayne Community Hospital
115Richmond University Medical CenterStaten Island, NY · Acute care−1.13%, 6th percentile−2.73%, 2nd percentile+0.90, 8th percentile20, 17th percentile−0.60%, 17th percentileCompare Richmond University Medical Center
116Auburn Community HospitalAuburn, NY · Acute care−1.29%, 5th percentile−1.16%, 23rd percentile+0.20, 35th percentile31, 55th percentile+0.13%, 55th percentileCompare Auburn Community Hospital
117Good Samaritan Hospital Of SuffernSuffern, NY · Acute care−1.31%, 4th percentile−1.48%, 16th percentile−0.58, 84th percentile27, 40th percentile−0.17%, 40th percentileCompare Good Samaritan Hospital Of Suffern
118Mount Sinai South NassauOceanside, NY · Acute care−1.36%, 4th percentile−1.51%, 15th percentile−0.57, 83rd percentile27, 41st percentile−0.15%, 41st percentileCompare Mount Sinai South Nassau
119Unity HospitalRochester, NY · Acute care−1.37%, 4th percentile−1.16%, 23rd percentile−0.06, 51st percentile32, 60th percentile+0.21%, 60th percentileCompare Unity Hospital
120Nyack HospitalNyack, NY · Acute care−1.44%, 3rd percentile−1.80%, 10th percentile+0.02, 46th percentile24, 30th percentile−0.36%, 30th percentileCompare Nyack Hospital
121South Brooklyn HealthBrooklyn, NY · Acute care−1.53%, 2nd percentile−1.46%, 16th percentile−0.20, 62nd percentile30, 52nd percentile+0.07%, 52nd percentileCompare South Brooklyn Health
122New York Community Hospital Of Brooklyn, Inc.Brooklyn, NY · Acute care−1.70%, 2nd percentile−1.70%, 12th percentile+0.35, 27th percentile——Compare New York Community Hospital Of Brooklyn, Inc.
123Maimonides Medical CenterBrooklyn, NY · Acute care−1.89%, 1st percentile−2.97%, 1st percentile+0.55, 18th percentile28, 44th percentile−0.08%, 44th percentileCompare Maimonides Medical Center
124St John's Episcopal Hospital At South ShoreFar Rockaway, NY · Acute care−1.95%, 1st percentile−2.95%, 1st percentile+1.46, 2nd percentile——Compare St John's Episcopal Hospital At South Shore
125St Joseph's Hospital Health CenterSyracuse, NY · Acute care−2.15%, 1st percentile−2.09%, 7th percentile+0.04, 45th percentile30, 52nd percentile+0.06%, 51st percentileCompare St Joseph's Hospital Health Center

About these rankings

Rankings use the 2026 release of CMS Care Compare data. Hospitals share a rank (“T”) when their values are equal, and only hospitals with a reported value for the sorted measure are ranked. Shading compares each value with every hospital in the country, so it doesn’t change with your filters. Small differences are often not statistically meaningful; use the methodology and glossary for context.

Readmissions penalty
Change to Medicare payments under the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program, which cuts payments (by up to 3%) to hospitals with more readmissions than expected. 0% means no penalty..
Net Medicare quality adjustment
Approximate combined change to the hospital's Medicare inpatient payments from the three pay-for-performance programs, added together: the readmissions penalty, the value-based purchasing bonus or penalty, and the 1% cut for hospital-acquired conditions. Inpatient prospective payment system hospitals only; Maryland hospitals are exempt..
Hospital-acquired condition score
Total score in the Hospital-Acquired Condition Reduction Program, from patient safety events and infections (weighted z-scores; 0 is about average, higher is worse). Medicare cuts payments 1% for the worst-scoring quarter of hospitals..
Value-based purchasing score
Hospital Value-Based Purchasing Total Performance Score (0-100), from outcomes, safety, patient experience and efficiency. It sets a Medicare bonus or penalty..
Value-based purchasing adjustment
Change to Medicare payments under Hospital Value-Based Purchasing: a bonus (positive) or penalty (negative, up to 2%) based on the Total Performance Score..